Read our reviews to see why our clients choose us.

“Sarah was pleasure to deal with…very knowledgeable…”

“Larry,

I wanted to let you know that we have finalized our family auto insurance for all (4) members with Plymouth Rock Insurance. I wanted to thank you for the outstanding customer service that was provided by Kara Kelliher as she is truly a “gem”! I appreciate the incredible research and effort your team put in to find us the best possible auto insurance rates especially with us being in a little bit of crisis mode with the pending cancellation (Nov 1st) of our insurance with Progressive! Kara was relentless in making sure we got every possible discount known to mankind and was such a pleasure to speak with on the phone. She clearly pays incredible attention to detail, and never missed a beat, and always followed up in a timely manner even with my young daughter who required a separate auto policy.

Just wanted you to know what a model employee you have in her, such a pleasure to work with and wish that we are all so lucky to deal with such a customer success professional!
Thank you very much!”

Craig & Lisa Nichols

“We have been with Walter May insurance for 14 years, and there is a simple reason we’ve stayed with a company this long. I can honestly say that I never worry about my exposure and know I am paying a fair price for the premiums. We have worked with many insurance companies and the service at Walter May Insurance is unmatched. One of the best moves our business has made is partnering with them 14 years ago!”

Chris O.

“We have been involved in several businesses over the last 45 years. In our opinion, Walter J May Insurance Agency is, by far, the best of them all. The company and its agents are excellent. We have multiple policies, both personal and business, with the company and they consistently shop, research rates and coverages, and initiate the calls to us. You can’t go wrong with Walter May Agency!”

Bill S.

“Their attention to detail and promptness in getting us correct information is second to none. I would highly recommend anyone looking for a quality insurance company to contact them.”

Gary S.